If you followed the very recent Les Blogs conference, you have already read coverage of the fracas between Six Apart founder Mena Trott and BBC Backstage's co-project lead Ben Metcalfe and the issue of a backchannel live chat that was posted on the screen behind speakers as they presented. It involved a call for civilityand some interchanges generally regarded as less than civil by both central participants.
I I was in an apparent minority, taking Mena’s side during the debate and I remain there now. Let me tell you my personal experience, which impacts my view:
Robert and l got off to a slow start in our own presentation the preceding day much to both our disappointments. About three minutes into a 45 minute presentation, I turned to the huge screens behind us where Loic Le Meur, the host-producer was showing the back channel conversation as Robert and I struggled to find our stride.
“YAWN. This is boring,” were the first words that caught my eye. The author was hiding behind an alias. This did not seem to me to be in any way constructive. It certainly did not make it easier for Robert and me to find our stride. I cannot conceive of any way this was helpful to the audience either. Over the rest of the day, as other speakers presented, the negative commentary continued. People who were not speakers continued to upstage speakers with this ongoing, overwhelmingly negative and snarky chat.
Tara Hunt, my Riya colleague, saw it otherwise. She wrote that she sees disrupting speakers via the back channel part of some wonderfully “magical extra layer.” My view is very different. I see it more like attending an art exhibit in which you are permitted to deface serious endeavors with spray paint if you do not like them.
At the break, Ben Metcalfe approached me for a word. I was pretty much prepared to go toe-to-toe with him, but I ended up liking him more than I had expected I would. He mostly talked and I mostly listened. He established that he was not just some kid passing nasty notes in the back of the classroom, but a contributing member of the blogosphere. It turned out I was familiar with some of his work, and admired it.
He also made a couple of other good points. He told me that he was 24 years old and wanted to know if when I was his age, had I executed the levels of respect that I would now have him display. When I was 24, I told him, I was trying to tear down the US government, I told him. However, I later reflected, my government was trying to put me in uniform and fight in a war that I considered a lot more offensive than a mediocre speech. And when Mena Trott was 24, she was co-starting a company that has changed the world.
But Ben's second point is the one that has stuck with me. He said that at conferences he attends, the back channel is used and enjoyed by significant percentages of the audience. They do this sort of thing all of the time. The difference is that at Les Blogs, they posted it on the screen while at others they did, well-in the back channel where the audience was not forced to watch it.
It seems to me, that came back to what had been Mena Trott’s central point before she blew her cool and got into a name-calling duel. We should be more civil, when we are speaking about others in public. When we publish comments we should get our facts straight because those facts last a very long time through searches. People should speak online as they do when they meet you face-to-face.
But Ben's key point was valid it seems to me. This chat stuff is part of free speech and those who enjoy it should certainly snark away. But, why on Earth it was being published tp upstage of each speaker remains beyond me. Even if it were favorable commentary, posting it behind the speakers is a visual distraction. And for a speaker to see what is being said about him or her, she or he has to turn their back to the audience.
The incident would never have happened and people would be talking today about the mastery of Ben Hammersley’s eloquence, and Global Voices vision than about this molehill that has become a mountain.
Technorati tag: lesblogs